Assignment
Using participant observation, I studied and reported on the
learning problems a teacher might face in learning with and
about technology.
Process
On
four different occasions, I met with an English teacher to
help design and build a web site for her high school creative
writing class.
She defined the content, while I planned and structured the
instruction and practice. We met for 90 to 120 minutes at
a time seated side by side with the teacher manipulating the
mouse and keyboard. I wrote my notes immediately after each
session.
Excerpts
Goal
Lucinda
has an extensive collection of thought-provoking postcards
she uses when she senses her students need fresh inspiration.
She wanted this resource to be available for students beyond
her classroom. Her goal was to create a web site containing
these pictures, articles about writing, and eventually samples
of student work.
Initial
questions
- How
can I put my postcards on the web?
- How
and where do I begin?
- Can
I do this?
Who
is the learner?
Lucinda has taught English to high school girls for several
years. The English department consists of a solid core of
excellent teachers who have been reluctant, if not resistant,
to integrating technology into their curriculum. Before June,
she had used a computer primarily to enter grades, word process,
and send email.
What
motivates her learning?
- Social
encouragement
- Classroom
problem
- Financial
compensation
Three
things coincided to motivate her to try to solve a problem
in her class with technology. Her friend, an art teacher,
had already committed to working on a web page project and
convinced Lucinda to join her. Lucinda also wanted to solve
a problem well suited to a web-based solution. Finally, a
trustee gives a stipend to encourage teachers to pursue summer
technology projects, and Lucinda, a teacher living in Silicon
Valley, found the additional income appealing.
Methodology
Prior to this project, Lucinda and I had a good, informal
working relationship. She was motivated and interested in
learning but as this process was quite new to her, I wanted
it to be as comfortable as possible. I hoped to build on our
established rapport, to understand her needs and to respond
to her learning process. During our sessions, I paid close
attention to her face, gestures, and language in an attempt
to monitor her understanding, evaluate her level of frustration,
and gage her interest.
She sat in front of the computer while I sat at her side coaching
and encouraging her to ask questions. I asked questions designed
to help me understand her goals, motivations, and understanding
of technology. I worked with her to define and articulate
her project and to make sure it developed in a way she found
pleasing and useful.
We began
each session by reviewing her work, marveling over her progress
and the growth of her site, and talking about issues she had
faced while she worked alone. She loved sharing her work to
an appreciative and interested audience. After introducing
a new idea, I encouraged her to practice and explore before
moving on. I concluded each session by leaving her with a
few ideas to explore and with a final opportunity for questions.
Lingering
questions
Will
she retain what she learned?
Lucinda seemed to enjoy using technology and was quite proud
of her results. However, I am not convinced that she will
continue to use her new skills. While she will continue to
rely on some of her new confidence and new understandings
of these technologies, if she does not practice her other
skills, she will forget much of the specific work we did this
summer. She seems to see web design as a supplement to her
class but not integral to it so I would be surprised if she
dedicated much time to it during a busy school year. Our success
lay in helping her gain a better understanding of computer
technology and opening her eyes to future possibilities.
Could
aspects of this process be reproduced?
The social motivation seemed particularly important for her
not only initially, but also as she continued to work on her
project. Lucinda loved showing people what she had done. She
often worked on her page with the art teacher. Even just sitting
next to her as we tried to figure out the endless mysteries
involved in web design seemed to help her concentrate and
have confidence to experiment. This is an enjoyable though
time-consuming model to teach technology. I cannot imagine
a school or school district having the resources to reproduce
this on a broader scale. However, it is critical to pay attention
to this need for social motivation and support. Uses of in-house
mentoring, each-one-teach-one and cooperative projects would
enhance a more traditional model of training and learning.
|